Let The Drink Talk Forum Index Let The Drink Talk
https://twitter.com/LetTheDrinkTalk
 
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 

3rd March Newcastle SMWS tasting

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Let The Drink Talk Forum Index -> Tasting Notes
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Spirit of Islay
Single Maltster
Single Maltster


Joined: 28 Aug 2005
Posts: 102
Location: Definitely not 55.640489,-6.107687

PostPosted: Fri Mar 03, 2006 9:42 pm    Post subject: 3rd March Newcastle SMWS tasting Reply with quote

Once again it’s The SMWS Newcastle tasting in the Vermont Hotel , in the company of the “Good Woman” , we sampled 5 whiskies served by Stephen , once again he used the “separate glasses” format , which is fine by me as it gives you the chance to compare them side by side . I’ve also included Mel’s notes this time .....

First up was a Speysider (Spey) 54.24 (Aberlour , 12yo , 56.8% , Dist Sept 1992 , 298 bottles , £40). From a refill Hoggy, a pale gold in colour .
Gordon:-
Nose – Aniseed balls and cherry blossom .
Taste – Very floral and Aniseed (very aniseed……)
Finish – A medium finish
Not a typical Speysider , you keep getting the Speyside floral starting to come through but then the aniseed puts a big boot in ! Believe it or not the tasting panel completely missed the aniseed !!!!
Mel :-
Nose –Very Aniseed bally ! Also Dental Topical anaesthetic (yes she’s a dental nurse ....) .
Taste – Aniseed !
Finish – long and guess what ?
Wow !

Second up was another Speysider , a 30yo Glencraig ( 104.6 , 51.1% , dist June 1974 , 199 bottles £83 ). Done on the Lomond stills at Glenburgie distillery , from a refill barrel it’s a pale straw colour .
Gordon:-
Nose – Marzipan , vanilla and pineapple cubes .
Taste – Spicy and a slight smoke (from where who knows )
Finish – Short and sweet .
Smooth as a babies bum ! A strange one in taste and finish , it’s there then it’s not there (confused ....you will be.....) .
Mel :-
Nose – Liquorice Sticks , very pungent first smell but doesn’t follow through with taste .
Having said that very drinkable, easy on the palate and liver .

The 3rd one was another Speysider (Deveron) 73.16 ( Aultmore , 17yo , 57.7% , dist Sept 1987 , 245 bottles £44 ) . Lemony gold in colour from a refill hoggy .
Gordon:-
Nose – Bags of honey (too much to be honest ) on top of the typical speyside nose .
Taste – Very dry , icing sugar and a touch rubber ?
Finish – Long and very dry .
Hmmm ….. over-powering honey , not one of my favourite distilleries .
Mel :-
Nose – First taste HONEY , over-powering smell of honey very off putting , feel reluctant to taste it …
Taste – smell of honey is very off putting …….didn’t like it !!

At last a non-speysider ! A highlander (Island) No. 121.9 , an 8yo Arran (56.8% , Dist April 1997 , 210 bottles £35 ) . From a refill hoggie , gold in colour.
Gordon:-
Nose – really weak after the previous 3 drams , apples and christmas cakes (spices raisins etc).
Taste – Menthol Cigarettes , peppery .
Finish – barely ! couldn’t figure it out !
In a nut shell , bland !
Mel :-
Nose – Vanilla essence
Taste – toffee (clotted cream devon toffee)
This (and No. 2 and 3 were battling to impress after N0.1’s wow factor .

Last of the night was an Islay , a 12yo Bowmore ( 3.111 , 60.3% , Dist dec 1992 , £38 ) . Another refill hoggie , antique copper in colour .
Gordon:-
Nose – dry Peat and lavender .
Taste – grow bag and smoke
Finish – Long , peaty / smoky
Closer to the 15yo than the 12yo O.B. , still not up to what I remember the old Bowmore tastes used to be .
Mel :-
Nose – Surgical spirit .
Taste – Ralgex Deep heat cream !! with water antiseptic taste disappears .
Didn’t like this at all – surgical smell very off putting .
Didn’t taste like the 12yo I remember from festival visits to Bowmore distillery ! (obviously prefer distillery bottling ) .

At the end we both came to the conclusion that the Glencraig was the star of the night !
So another tasting over , the next one to look forward to ( June , a week after the Feis Ile ! ) and it could be a corker .......

Slainté
Gordon
_________________
Homer's Hypothesis - One can never own too many Ardbegs.......

And a dedicated Islay Forum !!!!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Let The Drink Talk Forum Index -> Tasting Notes All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
subRed style by ktauber
Effex-Media Web Resources
Create your own free forum now!
Terms of Service Purchase Ad Removal Forum Archive Report Abuse